Just chiming in about clock/notes/timing… I tested out Cardinal a few weeks ago with Topography (clone of Mutable Grids) and noticed that when using the Dwarf’s internal clock, an occasional beat was being missed and causing the pattern being played to “pause” for a beat. Switching to external clock coming in from a USB MIDI device solved the problem and never missed a beat… literally!
Even if you can patch it - if it works - soon directly in the web browser, it would be possible to transfer the current patch from the mod to the PC - File->Deploy to PC option?
And possibly rename the parameters 1-24 individually would have the advantage that you can remember which controller regulates what. This refers only to the web browser, on the device you can name it individually.
I have wondered about this. The simplest approach I see possible is to have a button to copy Cardinal patch on MOD side to the clipboard, thus then allowing pasting that into Cardinal on desktop.
I will try this…
This is more tricky… the plugin settings screen can be customized in theory, though we never did it.
Main question is how to weak things, what the UX would look like for such a thing.
Do we simply make the knob/parameter titles editable? What then happens with the knob titles on the modgui side? (it is smaller in size for such text)
ok so I just tried this, and there are many issues.
the first and main blocker, is that browser clipboard is not accessible on non-https pages even if on the local network. even trying to request clipboard permissions from the browser, we are not allowed to use the main clipboard API here.
even if trying the more permissive document.execCommand("copy"), nothing happens.
the same code works on https pages, so it is not a browser problem.
besides that, giving a binary to the browser to put in the clipboard is also a problem. the cardinal saved data is compressed, which makes it binary. we would need to give extracted json (if the clipboard stuff worked anyway) to browser to copy, which presents a problem for modules that save any extra data, and size of the patch grows quickly this way too…
so I am afraid we will skip on this entirely for now. something to check up again in a future release.
Now as general question/thought, I am wondering what would be some requirements from the community to see this as a “stable” plugin, I mean not in beta.
It is a weird setup to compared to others, where you need to use a desktop tool in order to do anything useful with it, so perhaps it should have a dedicated application for remote control? (or is current approach of loading the plugin in a DAW and syncing/pushing to a MOD good enough?)
There is an issue with the screenshot sometimes, but easily fixable.
Some have suggested it needs a way to get patches out of MOD into the desktop. Not possible yet, but could be implemented why not.
Overall just curious on opinions from the community, on what you see Cardinal-in-MOD needs in order to feel more of a polished product.
In the long run it would be IMHO best if you can edit Cardinal also directly in the web browser, so on the device - double click on the screenshot opens Cardinal.
Also the option that you can create patches on the computer as well as - in the future - send patches from the web browser to the computer is awesome because you can create complex racks more freely, no matter (from) where.
If you could load in presets from the filemanager would be nice too.
In general, a big thank you to you and to Mod Devices!
I don’t use a daw at all, and everything I do is with hardware. The MOD GUI, and AUM are the only 2 pieces of software in my set up.
An app, browser, or device level control would be useful for me.
My desires are different, so without having a full external CV expander, I probably won’t use cardinal until I get the ability to create a modulation rack with full external CV control. The 2 CV outs included are awesome, but just isn’t anywhere close to being powerful in my synth set up.
I love the fact that this stuff is being included, but I won’t give up the hardware I paid for, to replace it with cardinal. I’d much rather have the option of using my mod device and an expander to utilize these digital modules into a physical set up.
Haha yeah and JACK was not a fun experience in Windows 10. It always gave me an error about the server failing to start. I finally figured out if I just ignored that, Cardinal would work and I had a great time using it with the Dwarf. Just looking to make things simpler and hoping VST will do just that!
Both Cardinal 22.06 x86 VST2 and x64 JACK versions seem to be working ok but both no longer send the preview image to the MOD ui. Tried both Cardinal and Cardinal Mini Mod plugins. I’m using a Mod Dwarf on the latest beta and a Windows 10 PC. Tried a fresh pedalboard and also rebooting the Windows machine and the Dwarf but no-go.
Also of note, using the Mod internal clock with step in the host time module still seems to miss beats. Using an external clock is still rock solid.