MODFather
Any guesstimate on when pedalboards DOT moddevices DOT com and downloads DOT moddevices DOT com might be back up?
Is this a matter of hosting space? If so, I, like others here, have hosting space I am wiling to donate for as long as is needed to ensure that the boards and plugins can be made available either by you or independent devs who want to continue creating plugins or code updates for the device.
@Lou0151, MOD isnât truly an open source project. If you or someone else, in âthe communityâ were to host their system(s), youâd become privy to their intellectual property (IP). Btw, IP is pretty much the antithesis of open source âŚ
In my view, this is emblematic of many things here. A lot could be said about this alone, but suffice it to say, there are philosophical issues here which underlay whatâs occurred.
Just a strange idea âout-of-the-boxâ, what about trying to sell your idea/end-product to Music Tribe as they have the capacity to carry out such productivity as they have a more linear ownership to their production-line?
The product can be carried out and you may even be able to expand production-line with their support.
You could throw a condition that required the new âparentâ company to deliver the product to backers.
At the moment the accounts are blocked and I cannot put them back on because I am not authorised to release any payment nor make decisions regarding the old company.
Hence, I am focusing on making the reboot happen so that I can simply reactivate the servers with the new company.
If the reboot does not happen, then I will get back here to speak about how we can release things in another manner.
I backed the MOD Duo with the extra foot switch and expression pedal. I was so impressed by it that I later took part in the Seedmatch funding (nothing big, but I believed in the product that much) and it didnât take me long to decide to also back the Dwarf.
I havenât received my expression pedal and Dwarf (tier 3 backer) and I was willing to wait it out, because I knew that, when it would finally show up, it would be good!
Thatâs one of the things that amazed me most about my MOD Duo: the quality of the product, both hardware and software. Something not many companies manage to do well both! Either their hardware is top notch, but the software sucks, or itâs the other way round! And of course, there is still a lot of room for improvement, but also only that: improvement, I never had any show-stopping issues, it never let me down.
I donât blame any of you guys, because Iâm sure you tried everything possible to keep the boat afloat. But sometimes thing just donât work out⌠I also donât understand some peopleâs remarks about it being obsolete when it will arrive: itâs an FX unit, not a laptop! People are still merrily using FX pedals from the 80âs and 90âs (I do, at least). It wonât stop working, because someone else makes an FX processor with a more powerful CPUâŚ
I also think that not fulfilling the outstanding crowdfunded units would be a very bad mistake (and not just because you still owe me 2 pieces): it would leave a very bad taste in peopleâs mouths and it would be something that would be following you for a long time. If you fulfill them, you would instantly have created a very good reputation. Donât fulfill and your reputation has the risk of being damaged beyond repair⌠Wrecking a good reputation is easy, building one is something else entirely: you can throw all the money in the world at it, it wonât become any better if you donât keep your promises.
So I really hope this reboot works out, even if itâs under a different name: as long as the quality of MOD is there, Iâll be more than happy.
I really thought IP and Open Source were going hand in hand. For instance with the GNU GPL, the author of the source is still owning the IP on the source. And they precisely use that IP to impose the strict rules of the GPL on the source code to control what is done with it. Open Source is different from simply having something in the public domain.
That said, I understand that the costs of producing something like the Dwarf are quite high. Wouldnât it have been a good strategy to add an cheaper-to-produce entry level product to the MOD catalog in the first place, that would have been a source of income and at better tool for penetrating the market ?
Something based on easy to source off-the-shelf components ? Sort of better packaged MODEP sort of thing ? That would have exposed the excellent MOD concept to larger consumer base and created a larger market for upper hand Dwarf and MODX. I suppose you thought of that @gianfranco
@LievenDV first of all thanks for your really to-the-point yet complete feedback, showing all your feelings in a respectful and super understandable way, as always.
I will not go in to answer you on everything just after reading even because a lot of the questions, doubts and/or suggestions that you are giving are not really up to me to decide. Rest assured that I personally share your opinion in quite a lot of them.
I will only answer now to this oneâŚ
The device will not stop working, simply the plugin store and any updates are currently not available. What is in your device is in your device.
If it gives you any trust, I will have quite some gigs during September with a particular project of mine and the core of my setup in that project is a Dwarf and a DuoX. Actually, we will even add more functionalities to the DuoX and (now with the SPDIF separated out) we will use it also for some backing tracks. Iâm not sure if this gives you a bit more trust or not really on using it, but nothing should be wrong with that.
Also, did we try to approach big youtubers like Beato, Paul Davids, Mc Knight, Mary Spender, Rhett Shull, Darrell Braun etc⌠despite many of them seemingly being more into ârealâ amps, they also talk about modelers sometime (usually high end, like Kemper, or Neural DSP).
I know EytschPi42 and SuperFunAwesomeHappyTime did something about the MOD Duo, but they are not in the same leagueâŚ
At this stage, what is the status of the MODEP project ? I donât know too much about it, so I am asking if it would make sense that the MOD community try to get a bit closer to them in order to unite forces somehow ?
YeahâŚwell most of them have a âprice tagâ that would leave a few more backers waiting for their Dwarf - sorry for the directness here, but itâs just how things work.
What are the plugins you are interested in ? I think there is a way to extract them from another unit and install them in an other one manually via SSH. I donât have my Dwarf yet (just a Duo), but maybe other people around here have the plugins you want and would be happy to share.
Would someone like at MOD be able to provide us with a little script or something to make that operation easier ? @falkTX maybe ?
Donât take me wrong, I believe these are the guys that can push quite some sales for a week or two. Now the problem is if that fits in your cash balance and cash flow.
Oh man. This is sad. Iâve been on both sides of this situation more times than I care to think about. I just missed out on the Linux IPO craziness. Our mgt pulled the plug a couple days before it was time, divied up the money and split. We got old laptops as compensation instead of the $millions in options.
Startups are hard. Most fail. We can call it crowdfunding, but in the end, this is just the same as any market - you find investors and you give it your blood. Sometimes it works. Usually it doesnât.
I hope you can reboot in some way - Iâve been kind of holding off with mine in hopes of a better workflow set up or at least good documents, and kind of waiting for a couple of things like the guitar synth stuff. I was gonna load up a few plugins, but I guess thatâs on hold for a while.
So far, it has given me many hours of dial twiddle experimentation fun, and even a few Gilmour fantasies. (I admit it.)
Anyway, best of luck. I think the concept is viable, especially with a good angel.