Hi everyone,
In preparation for MOD OS 1.15, I’ve spent a couple of days measuring the analog inputs and outputs of all three MOD units on the bench. The goal was to obtain a simpler and cleaner input gain control for MOD OS 1.15, and also to obtain numbers that can be put in the manuals.
Here is what was found and what is changing in the HMI. Your feedback is super duper welcome ![]()
How I measured
A calibrated audio interface sent 1 kHz test tones into each unit and recorded its outputs. Levels are in dBu (RMS). I measured both inputs and both outputs of every unit, with TS and TRS cables.
The signal path
Every number below refers to a point in this chain, from input jack to output jack:
input jack
→ analog gain stage ┐ together: Input Gain
→ converter gain ┘
→ converter (analog → digital)
→ input LEDs
→ [Dwarf, Duo X: input noise gate]
→ your pedalboard
→ [Dwarf, Duo X: output compressor]
→ [Dwarf, Duo X: Pedalboard Gain, digital, −30 to +20 dB]
→ output LEDs
→ Output Gain (Output Volume on the Duo; in the converter, per output)
→ converter (digital → analog)
→ output jack
What follows from it:
- Input Gain sets how much signal reaches the converter. Too little and your signal sits low in the digital chain, so amp sims, drives and compressors see a weaker signal than they expect; too much and the converter clips. The input LEDs show exactly that point.
- Everything between the two converters is digital and has the full scale ceiling (DBFS). Gain plugins and Pedalboard Gain move your signal relative to this reference and have to keep it under the ceiling before output. Once the output LEDs hit red, the unit is at its maximum output level, and more digital gain only adds clipping.
- Output Gain comes after the output LEDs. If Output Gain is turned down, the LEDs can look healthy or even clipping red while the jacks are quiet. That’s the first thing to check when a sound engineer says your signal is low.
- Pedalboard Gain is one setting for the whole device, despite its name; it is not stored per pedalboard.
- Hardware Bypass (Duo and Duo X) connects the input jack straight to the output jack with relays, around all of the above.
Inputs
All three units have the same kind of front end: an analog gain stage followed by the converter’s own gain control (the PGA). I found one problem on all three: the lowest input gain settings turn the converter gain down below the point where the analog stage runs out. The analog stage then saturates while the input LED still shows yellow, not red. That distortion is hard and easy to miss. It is easy to verify. Simply turn your input gain to -7 dB or below and you’ll never be able to clip the LEDs red.
The highest level each input takes cleanly (the input LED turns red), at the lowest clean gain and at 24 dB more:
| Dwarf | Duo X | Duo | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest clean gain | +7.8 dBu (1.9 V) | +7.7 dBu (1.9 V) | +4.9 dBu (1.4 V) |
| 24 dB more gain | −16.2 dBu | −16.0 dBu | −18.9 dBu |
- At the lowest clean gain, the Dwarf and Duo X take about the same level as high-end reverb and delay pedals, a little less than the instrument input of a typical USB audio interface. The Duo has about 3 dB less room.
- Turning the gain up does not make the input noisier relative to your signal: the front end’s own noise rises together with the signal. So the advice is the usual one: lowest setting that gets your loudest playing into the yellow.
Outputs
Maximum output level with Output Gain at its top setting (full scale):
| Dwarf | Duo X | Duo | |
|---|---|---|---|
| TRS (balanced) cable | +9.4 dBu (2.3 V) | +3.5 dBu (1.2 V) | +7.0 dBu (1.7 V) |
| TS (unbalanced) cable | +3.5 dBu (1.2 V) | +3.5 dBu (1.2 V) | +7.0 dBu (1.7 V) |
- All outputs stay clean right up to full scale.
- Only the Dwarf has fully balanced outputs: a TRS cable into a balanced input gives 6 dB more level. On the Duo and Duo X, TRS and TS give the same level.
- Into a guitar amp or other pedals, all of these are plenty. Into a mixer or interface line input, they are about 6 dB below typical studio gear, so you may need a bit more trim on the mixer side.
Level through the unit
Because input and output full scale differ, a unit with the lowest clean input gain, Output Gain at the top and a pedalboard that doesn’t change the level does not pass your signal at exactly the level it receives:
| Dwarf, TS | Dwarf, TRS | Duo X | Duo | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Level through the unit | 4.3 dB quieter | 1.6 dB louder | 4.2 dB quieter | 2.1 dB louder |
Changes made to level controls in MOD OS 1.15
In order to make life simpler the following changes were made.
- Since the biggest headroom is at the former -6dB point, that becomes the new starting point and referenced 0 dB.
- The workable range is 0 to +24 dB. Any extra gain above that is too noisy, so +24 dB is now the maximum gain applied.
- The controller will display at the same time, the gain applied, and the maximum analog level in dBu which clips the input at the set gain setting, with the ranges shown above.
- The analog gain stage before the codec has 3 discrete stages and switching from one to the other makes the audio “pop”. A small tick was added to the horizontal bar on the switching point (18.5 dB), so you’re aware of an incoming"pop".
- The output level control is renamed to “Output Max Level” and now displays the maximum analog level at the setting in dBu. So you can now tell the sound tech guy of the venue how much signal you’re sending. Because the Dwarf has different values for TS and TRS connections, the HMI tells the TS value and you should add +6 dBu when you’re using TRS cables.
The “Pedalboard Out Gain” does not seem popular - though the poll did not have many votes to be conclusive - and surely it is confusing. Maybe that can become a “per pedalboard” adjustment, but we’ll see. I have the impression that it was created as a workaround to when users did not add the volume out in their pedalboards, but I am not sure. I believe we can find better solutions and I’d like to get your opinion on this.
I think there is still space for more improvement, but I am happy about how it is now. I’m thinking on a way to adjust the gain automatically in a sort of “learn” procedure, but it still needs more though.
Please let me know what you think and how you feel about it, once you try the incoming RCs for MOD OS 1.15.
Graziemille
Gianfranco